Hot Water Service (Whats hot and whats not)

Having the correct hot water service installed can cut your electricity use down significantly. When we bought the house it had an electric hot water service as do most houses in Tasmania.
original electric hot water

original electric hot water

Natural gas supply is very limited at the moment and bottled gas is the next best but very expensive.

Originally we started looking at solar hot water systems. There are two different kinds available; flat panel and evacuated tube. Both of these need some sort of back up heating in Tasmania’s cooler climate, being quite far south in the Southern Hemisphere.

To find out about Flat Plate and Evacuated tube CLICK HERE:

Mandy likes to cook with gas so our initial research was into solar hot water with instantaneous LP gas booster. That way we would have LP gas to cook with also.

As we did more research we discovered another type of Hot Water System called a heat pump. Now in Tasmania just to confuse the issue reverse cycle air conditioners are called heat pumps as well. These are two seperate beasties but related.

Heat pumps for hot water take heat out of the surrounding air even down to -10C and transfer it to water thus heating it up. They do this by the use of a compressor just like a fridge or air conditioner. Still electric they use approx 80% less power than a conventional electric hot water system and attract the Federal government rebates if replacing an exisiting electric hot water system. Our direction of thinking started to veer from solar to heat pump technology.

There are several advantages to heat pumps in Tasmania when viewed against Solar hot water.

A good explanation of the different types of solar and efficient electric hot water systems can be found at https://www.choice.com.au/home-improvement/water/hot-water-systems/buying-guides/hot-water-systems

Heat Pump

  • Can be fitted quickly thus saving electricity costs quicker
  • No extra plumbing needed
  • Attracts more Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs)* in Tasmania than solar hot water
  • Takes heat out of air 24 hours a day
  • Still works on Aurora HydroHeat tariff
  • Cheaper than Solar HWS to buy and install
  • No heavy loads on roof
  • No booster required
  • Solar hot water panels can be added later
  • $1000 Federal rebate available if replacing existing electric HWS

 Solar Hot Water Service

  • Extra plumbing runs to roof required
  • Gas booster likely to be used most of the time in the winter
  • Gas must be fitted to attract Federal Government rebate
  • Less room available on roof for photovoltaic system later on

Most of the research was done on the internet and took many hours of looking and reading, finding a manufacturer and then chasing up leads to see if they were available in Tasmania and then in Launceston, our closest large centre (pop 67,000)  but the aim of this site is to bring it all together.

Major manufacturers of either solar HWS or Heat Pumps:

Our new Siddons heat pump

Our new Siddons heat pump

Our research led us to decide upon a heat pump hot water system. The next step was to find out which ones were available in Launceston. A great source of ideas and trades and products is the Building Selection Centre at 262 York St, Launceston. A browse through their many displays gave us brochures on heat pumps, double glazing, roofing, solar hws and much more. As the house progresses I am sure that we will return again and again.

Simultaneous research on the internet and the home ideas centre narrowed the choices down to three products; two heat pumps, Quantum and Siddons; and one evacuated tube solar system by Hills.

The solar system by Hills were distributed by Apollo Energy, 110 Elizabeth St, Launceston (Hills have now gone out of business) and the two heat pumps by Jessups Retravision, 106-108 Charles Street, Launceston.

Costs and comparisons

Quantum heat pump

  • Cost (as of July 2008) $3670 + $600 installation
  • 250 litre glass lined tank
  • 5 year warranty on tank
  • Kw/hour output 3.53kwh
  • Ambient air temperature -10 to +40C
  • Refrigerant type R134A
  • hot water heating rate L/hr@20C = 75
  • Power input 0.986kw
  • RECS zone 4 (tas) 26
  • Attracts $1000 Federal rebate if replacing existing electric hws

Siddons heat pump

  • Cost (as of July 2008) $4290 + $800 istallation
  • 320 litre stainless steel tank
  • 10 year warranty on tank, 4 year warranty on compressor
  • Kw/hour output 5 kwh
  • Ambient air temperature -5 to +45C
  • Refrigerant type R417A
  • hot water heating rate L/hr@20C = 106
  • Compressor input kw 1.38
  • RECS zone 4 (tas) 30
  • Attracts $1000 Federal rebate if replacing existing electric hws

Hills solar evacuated tube system LPG boosted

  • Cost $5160 + LPG booster approx $900 + installation of unit + installation of LPG bottles
  • RECS zone 4 (tas) 26Attracts $1000 Federal rebate if replacing existing electric hws
  • Attracts $1000 Federal rebate if replacing existing electric hws

We decided on a Siddons heat pump and ordered it from Jessups Retravision on 12th July 2008. We paid $4290 less RECS of $1320 plus installation of approx $800. We then got our $1000 back from Federal government approx six weeks later. Total cost to us $2770. It was fitted on 22/07/2008. So far it has been great, there’s always plenty of hot water even on the coldest mornings.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Hot Water Service (Whats hot and whats not)

  1. brilliant site. I just had 1.5 kw pv panels fitted today cost 3K after rebates. so excited about it all now up all night looking into HW. Your site has giving me the answers I need living in Hobart I was so close to going solar but now swayed by you to a Siddons heat pump

  2. Hi,

    Thanks so much for your research you have saved me so much time! I am in Devonport and our hot water system has just sprung a leak. I had always been going to go solar, but had heard people were paying more to boost it because their tarrif for boosting was not the cheaper water tarrif rate.

    The other option I am considering is gas, as we do have gas available in Devoport. I am not sure about the running cost, but the other consideration for me has also been the environmental cost.

    As far as I understand Tasmania is now on the national grid so if we do get power from the big island we could well be using coal fired, although my understanding is we are supplying Victoria. Very hard to make a decision that is the best for the pocket and the best environmentally. So that brings me back to the heat pump option, do you think it uses less electricity as compared to a solar with a booster?

    Would you have gone with gas if it was in your area? I still have to investigate that option.

    Anyway good luck with your renovations and thanks so much for posting your research!

    Annie D

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s